Skip to main content
Menu
The House You Dreamed About Now Keeps You Up at Night

The House You Dreamed About Now Keeps You Up at Night

By Hamid Salehi,Published: November 16, 2026• Updated: November 16, 2026• 9 min read
homeownershipproperty-taxhome-insurance

As you lie awake, you keep thinking about the property tax bill that’s sitting on your kitchen counter. All you want is for your house to feel like a home, but at night, it feels more like a bad investment. You had planned for the purchase price.

You weren’t prepared for the things that break without permission. Nobody told you that perfectly good plumbing could simply burst without warning or that your furnace would stop working on a regular Sunday afternoon. When the thought crosses your mind that life felt easier when you rented, you push it away, embarrassed to even admit it.

The day they moved in

In June 2021, Lauren Morgan and her husband moved into their first home in Norwood, Massachusetts, south of Boston. On the very day they moved in, the air conditioner broke. Lauren remembers that day as the first time she asked herself whether buying the house had been a mistake.

Plumbing trouble followed, along with a leak that opened a hole in the dining room ceiling. During the coldest week of winter, the furnace died. Speaking to NPR in March 2022, Lauren estimated that all of these repairs “probably cost us around $20,000.” The landlord would have had to deal with this if they were still renting, she opined.

As a tenant, you always dreamed about the moment a house would become your home. Now that you have it, all you want to do is call up the landlord whenever there’s a problem. Except, you’re the landlord and your home has become something you’re standing watch over.

The dream, and the bills nobody sings about

In December 1931, speaking in Washington to a White House conference on home ownership, Herbert Hoover told a national radio audience, “But they never sing songs about a pile of rent receipts.” Nobody sings about the envelope from the county or the bills that keep climbing, either. Many of us believed buying the house was the finish line. We planned for the purchase price and never added up all the other costs that followed, sometimes unexpected.

There’s nothing wrong with wanting a place of your own. But when the house you’ve worked so hard for starts to feel heavy, you might wonder if it’s your fault that the math stopped working.

Lynn Rosner bought her family’s dream house in Los Angeles in 1968 for $64,000. Her property tax was $1,800 a year. By 1976, these same taxes came to $3,500 a year. In June 1978, Lynn told TIME that the year before, “we stopped going out, we did no entertaining and bought no clothes. We can’t take a vacation. We can’t lead a normal life.”

Families are still experiencing the same shock when they open a bill. Kaliff Chilembwe had always dreamed of buying a home. Eight years earlier, he bought his home in the Grand Crossing neighborhood of Chicago’s South Side. “Mine. Mine. Mine. I’ve got all my investments in it. When we got here, it was empty. Now it’s full,” he told CBS in December 2025.

Then he opened his property tax bill. His property taxes had gone up by 118%. “We looked at each other and said, ‘Why?’ And then we said, ‘How?’” he said.

Wanting out

Wanting to sell a home you dreamed about can feel like you’re going backward as a grown-up. Complaining about owning a house is not something people want to hear. You haven’t failed. You made a choice based on a payment you knew you could afford. A bill that climbs on its own is out of your control.

Someone to call

You might think you wish you were renting again, but there’s nothing about the lease you actually miss. What you miss is having someone to call.

One of the easiest ways to cope is to build a list of trusted “fixers.” You can start by asking a neighbor who they trust when something goes wrong. Having a heating tech and a plumber already picked out doesn’t make repairs free. It does ease the panic of trying to find someone in a hurry when something gives out.

You can also call someone on the money side. A HUD-approved housing counselor can sit down with you and go through your bills, often at no cost. HUD is the federal housing department, and its line, 800-569-4287, finds a counselor near you.

About a year after Eric Shannon and his wife moved into their home in Jefferson County, Colorado, he received an email from his insurer that said “looking forward to renewal.” He clicked and saw that his premium was jumping nearly 50%, from around $4,500 a year to $6,600. This was on top of their mortgage, taxes and daycare. In February 2026, he told KUNC that he worked with an independent agency that bundled his car and home policies and found a lower rate with a smaller company, which was a relief.

You can also question your home’s assessed value with the local assessor or ask about a homestead exemption. The assessed value is the value your county puts on your home to figure the tax. A homestead exemption is a tax cut many states give on the home you live in, and in most places you have to apply for it.

The same house on the morning after a snowstorm, with the front walk and the car buried in snow.

The real question

Lying awake at night, your mind probably jumps to the scariest question: Should I sell my house and go back to renting? First, you want to understand whether the money you bring in each month covers the costs of keeping the house. This money could be a pension, a regular salary or Social Security. You don’t want to count any inconsistent money, like tax refunds.

As a simple way to see where you stand, add up a full year of what the house costs. This includes property taxes, utilities, insurance, your mortgage if you have one, any homeowners or condo association fees and a repair reserve. Divide this figure by 12, and compare it to your monthly income.

For the repair reserve, Fannie Mae’s rule of thumb is to budget 1% to 4% of a home’s value each year for repairs. Once your house passes 30 years old, you’ll want to lean closer to 4%. By our calculation on a $300,000 house, that comes to between $250 and $1,000 a month. These figures are based on a budgeting guide and not what people actually spend. Setting aside even some of this money is a good start.

Your escrow account might be the reason your monthly payments jumped even with a fixed-rate loan. Many owners pay insurance and taxes into this holding account through their mortgage company. Every year, the company reviews your account and can add a catch-up amount if your account ran short. If your loan doesn’t have escrow, this jump simply lands in your mailbox as a bigger bill.

If leaving is the answer

Selling might be the right answer. It’s not a failure to leave a home you worked hard to buy.

That said, leaving your home does come with costs, and so does going back to renting. Real estate agent commissions have traditionally run up to about 6% of the sale price in total. If you’re selling a $300,000 home, the agents would be getting up to $18,000 in commission alone. That’s before any other selling costs, repairs and moving expenses. A new lease also means a security deposit, first month’s rent and the chance that the landlord will raise the rent or decide not to renew.

You’re not the first person to feel stuck in a home they once dreamed about. In 2007, Sergio Martinez was 41 and living in Miami in a five-bedroom home he had bought about three years earlier for $405,000. When he bought the property, his tax was $2,800 a year. Florida had a rule that capped the yearly rise in a home’s assessed value at 3% once an owner qualified. By the time he qualified, his tax had jumped to $7,400 and he was working two jobs to cover his insurance and taxes.

The cap ended when a house was sold, and the buyer was taxed on the full value. If he were to sell the house, the new owner would be looking at an annual tax of almost $20,000. “That’s a big reason I’d have trouble finding a buyer for this house,” he told TIME. He said, “I’m essentially in jail in my own house.”

Bar chart of the yearly property tax on Sergio Martinez’s Miami home: $2,800 when he bought it, $7,400 by 2006, and almost $20,000 for a new buyer if he sold it in 2007, because Florida’s cap on tax increases ended when a house was sold.

What can be fixed

The house will always be something you feel you need to watch over. It’s your home. Things will break in a place you own. Most of these breaks can be fixed, and plenty of inconveniences can wait until the morning.

You can love the roof over your head and still feel overwhelmed by the bills.

After the broken air conditioner, the furnace that died and the hole in the dining room ceiling, Lauren Morgan told NPR, “I don’t know if it’s cognitive dissonance, myself justifying that, like, I’ve had to put in all this effort now, so I must really love the house. But for me, it really is a space that I love. And when I go home, almost every day, I feel grateful that I have that space that is my own.”

Sources

  • NPR, Consider This, “Some Who Rushed To Buy Homes During The Pandemic Now Regret It” (March 16, 2022), for Lauren Morgan’s first year in her house and her words: npr.org
  • The American Presidency Project, Herbert Hoover’s address to the White House Conference on Home Building and Home Ownership (December 2, 1931): presidency.ucsb.edu
  • TIME, “Sound and Fury over Taxes” (June 19, 1978), for Lynn Rosner: time.com; and “Behind Florida’s Property Tax Revolt” (June 12, 2007), for Sergio Martinez: time.com
  • CBS News Chicago (December 2025), for Kaliff Chilembwe: cbsnews.com
  • KUNC, “For Colorado homeowners, insurance is taking a bigger bite of the budget” (February 23, 2026), for Eric Shannon’s insurance renewal: kunc.org
  • Fannie Mae, “How to Build Your Maintenance and Repair Budget,” for the 1% to 4% rule of thumb: fanniemae.com
  • Federal Reserve staff note, “Commissions and Omissions: Trends in Real Estate Broker Compensation” (May 12, 2025), for commissions of up to about 6% in total, with data through 2023: federalreserve.gov
  • U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, for housing counselors and the line that finds one near you, 800-569-4287: hud.gov
  • Arcanomy calculation: 1% and 4% of a $300,000 house, divided by 12 ($250 and $1,000 a month), and 6% of $300,000 ($18,000), the top of the traditional range.
Share this post
Hamid Salehi
Hamid Salehi

Founder of Arcanomy

Ph.D. engineer and MBA writing about wealth psychology, financial clarity, and why most money advice misses the point.

Enjoyed this post?

Subscribe for more insights, tips, and updates, straight to your inbox.

We respect your privacy and will never share your information.